Skip to content
Account
Customize
What’s Coming
FAQs
Sign Up
Gift Baskets
Menu
Account
Customize
What’s Coming
FAQs
Sign Up
Gift Baskets
Shop By Vendor
Produce
Bakery
Meat, Seafood & Vegan
Dairy & Eggs
Ready Meals
Coffee & Tea
Beverages & Alcohol
Pantry
Bakery
Bread
Treats
Produce
Meat & Seafood
Plant Based Meats
Seafood
Beef
Chicken
Pork
Duck
Lamb
Cured Meats
Dairy & Eggs
Eggs
Cheese & Butter
Milk & Cream
Yogurt
Ready Meals
Soup
Chili
Pies
Quiches
Pasta & Lasagna
Pizza
Entrées
Sides
Pantry
Beverages
Chips & Crisps
Chocolate
Canned Goods
Coffee & Tea
Condiments
Crackers
Dips
Energy Bites
Home & Body
Honey & Maple Syrup
Kitchenware
Nuts & Seeds
Oils & Vinegars
Pasta
Sauces
Seasoning
Spreads
Snacks
Alcohol
Beer
Wine
Liquor
Vegan
Menu
Shop By Vendor
Produce
Bakery
Meat, Seafood & Vegan
Dairy & Eggs
Ready Meals
Coffee & Tea
Beverages & Alcohol
Pantry
Bakery
Bread
Treats
Produce
Meat & Seafood
Plant Based Meats
Seafood
Beef
Chicken
Pork
Duck
Lamb
Cured Meats
Dairy & Eggs
Eggs
Cheese & Butter
Milk & Cream
Yogurt
Ready Meals
Soup
Chili
Pies
Quiches
Pasta & Lasagna
Pizza
Entrées
Sides
Pantry
Beverages
Chips & Crisps
Chocolate
Canned Goods
Coffee & Tea
Condiments
Crackers
Dips
Energy Bites
Home & Body
Honey & Maple Syrup
Kitchenware
Nuts & Seeds
Oils & Vinegars
Pasta
Sauces
Seasoning
Spreads
Snacks
Alcohol
Beer
Wine
Liquor
Vegan
Search
Search
Butter Tarts (Plain)
Barrie, Ontario
Famous Butter Tarts, featured in The New York Times
6 pack
$
11.95
Butter Tarts (Plain) quantity
Add to cart
Related products
Don's Muskoka Bakery
Key Lime Loaf Cake
$
11.95
Add to cart
Don's Muskoka Bakery
Cranberry Lemon Loaf Cake
$
9.95
Add to cart
Fox's Bakery
Fox’s White Loaf
$
3.75
Add to cart
Don's Muskoka Bakery
Apple Cinnamon Loaf Cake
$
9.95
Add to cart